The Pros & Cons of a DIY Tub-to-Shower Conversion
Are you considering a bathroom renovation? Have you fallen out of love with your current bathtub setup and want to replace it with a more modern and accessible shower enclosure?
An increasing number of homeowners are replacing their old bathtubs with contemporary, feature-rich walk-in showers. Whether you’re making the changes to accommodate the limited mobility of your senior years or prefer the clean aesthetics of shower enclosures – a critical factor to consider is whether you want to take the DIY route or get the help of professionals.
In this post, we weigh the pros and cons of a DIY tub-to-shower conversion to help you make an informed decision.
Pros of DIY Tub-To-Shower Conversion
Here are a few benefits of rolling up your sleeves and tackling the project by yourself:
- Customization: DIY projects offer you maximum flexibility and personalization. You can choose the shower enclosure, fixtures, tiles, accessories, caddies, and other design elements to align with your style and vision.
- Skill Development: Undertaking a complex DIY project like a tub-to-shower conversion could provide a valuable learning experience. It helps you acquire new skills and improve your practical knowledge of plumbing, home renovation, design, and construction. This knowledge can guide you while tackling future renovation projects.
- Flexibility: You can work on the project at your own pace. For example, you can decide to tackle the project only on weekends if you have a busy schedule during the weekdays.
- Sense of Accomplishment: Completing a massive DIY project like a tub-to-shower conversion gives you immense pride in your work. Seeing your old tub transform into a modern, functional shower is rewarding and satisfying.
Cons of DIY Tub-To-Shower Conversion
While there are several benefits of undertaking a DIY tub-to-shower conversion, there are also potential downsides and challenges to consider:
- Lack of Skill and Knowledge: Removing an old tub and installing a new shower enclosure is a complex project requiring carpentry, and plumbing expertise. If you lack the necessary skills and prior experience, you might encounter challenges that could lead to safety hazards or expensive mistakes.
- Risk of Mistakes: Without professional expertise, there’s a higher chance of making mistakes during the project. Incorrect waterproofing, faulty plumbing connections, or faulty installations could lead to water damage and other significant issues.
- Time-Consuming: A DIY tub-to-shower conversion is a challenging task that probably won’t be completed within a few hours. It involves multiple steps, such as removing and disposing of the existing tub, prepping the space, installing the shower components, finishing plumbing, cleaning up, and more. Completing the project is time-consuming and will most likely take longer than you expect.
- Impact on Potential Resale Value: While a DIY tub-to-shower conversion is immensely satisfying, it could impact the potential resale value of your home. Unconventional designs or poorly executed projects do not appeal to buyers and could cause your home to stay on the market without any interested buyers.
Trust Bath Experts for Hassle-Free Tub-To-Shower Conversions
Replacing your old bathtub with a modern shower enclosure is one of the most affordable and easiest ways to give your bathroom a facelift and make it more suitable for family members with limited mobility. Bath Experts, the leading bathroom remodeling company in Ohio and Indiana, is the name you can trust for tub-to-shower conversions.
Whether you want to add a spa-like feel to your bathroom or make the bath area more accessible, we can help you replace your old, worn-out bathtub with a modern shower enclosure that aligns with your needs and style. The best part – we can complete the project within 1 to 2 days so that you can begin enjoying your shower as quickly as possible.
Browse our shower enclosure models for a custom shower that fits your dream tub-to-shower conversion project. Schedule a free design consultation with one of our expert bathroom remodelers, or call us at 866-548-0827 to discuss your needs.
Get $500 OFF Your Tub or Shower Project* PLUS
18 Months No Payments No Interest*
Lock in this offer, only when you book through our website
Expires 9/30/26
Reviews
Shower replacement- work done by Jason and Ben, very professional, cautious and answered all of our questions, cleaned up all areas inside and out. Highly recommend Bath Experts as well as Jason and Ben! Thank you for making this process stress free!
Great experience with Nate from their install team. On time, worked hard all day. Finished product looks great. A big upgrade from the builder grade tub / shower insert we got with the house originally.
Bath Experts were professional and experienced from the initial estimate to the installation. They were on time, called before they came and kept us informed of what was being done. The final project turned out beautifully and was completed in only two days. There was no mess for us to clean up. If I had it all to do over, I would call them again. I am so pleased with our new shower! My husband has already started recommending them to family and friends. Thank you Bath Experts!
My experience with Bath Experts were absolutely great my bathroom install is gorgeous I highly recommend them shaggy and Joey did a great job highly professional and knowledgeable
The 2 young fellas that installed my new tub were quick and polite very good at it amazing job all around I would recommend them highly to anyone who ask
Jacuzzi Bath Experts did an amazing job! Our new walk-in shower looks wonderful! Celius, Jackson and their other helper were very professional and extremely knowledgeable about their work. It only took 6 hours from start to finish, including cleanup! I was very impressed! We are very satisfied with our choice. We would recommend these guys to family and friends, and actually have already.
Anthony R. did a great job, kept me informed about progress, was kind to my dog and considerate of me having only one bathroom. It looks great and any customer would be grateful for such a terrific installer.
Today I had the greatest experience with bath experts. Jason and Levi came to my house around 9:00 and installed me the most beautiful shower and replacing my tub. They were clean and efficient and you can't even tell they were here I would recommend their work to anyone. They were also very knowledgeable on the equipment they were installing. They explained all functions and also the best way to keep it clean and looking good.
We have been very happy from start to finish with the process and work done by Bath Experts. They have all been professional, friendly and efficient. We love our new shower! Thank you all.
Service was excellent and the installer was great. He did an outstanding job and explained the process thoroughly. Highly recommend him for future work.
Had a walking shower installed. The floor or the shower is nonslip which makes it really nice that we dont have to use a Mat and safer for by 88 year old mom. The seat folds up so its not in the way of getting in or out. You pick the grab bars, the shelves, you want and we also had the caddie added and so glad we did because I love it. The young men that installed the shower, Max and Jackson were awesome young men, knew what they were doing and very pleasant. We are very pleased with the shower.
Very happy with our new shower! Our installer Cam was awesome - very professional, polite and very personable! Would highly recommend this company for ease of process. They kept us updated every step of the ordering process up to the expected installation date. The shower itself is beautiful and is a welcomed addition to our home!
The installation went smoothly! David & Jason accompanied outstanding work ethics as a team. Just B4 their arrival the area was hit with a flurries rainstorm. They quickly identified an adjustment for measuring & cutting the materials by asking if they was room in the garage, there was ample room for David’s expertise and Jason’s always ready to assist. It was a WET JOB Long Day they championed the job to completion the same day August 10, 2026. It was a big job and big decision to have the childhood cast iron tub removed!!! The new & improved shower/tub/jacuzzi fixtures at our 81year young home is simply beautiful. Thank U Bath Experts Team
I just had my walk in shower installed today. I was at work, the installer called me to verify where I wanted the safety bars. I came home to a beautiful brand new walk in shower. Happy customer!
Danon came out to give me an estimate and I was absolutely delighted with the whole process. He told me so much information about jacuzzi products that I wasn’t aware of. I’m electrician by trade so I’ve been around the building industry for years. Absolutely a great product with transferable lifetime warranty for me and I think 2 years for new owners if I sell. Thanks Danon.
We had excellent service through Bath Experts. The salesman was very informative. The installers were fantastic. The walk-in shower is absolutely beautiful. We couldn’t be happier.
Scheduled a total shower replacement and was very satisfied with the materials and the expertise of the 2 replacement technicians. Arrived at scheduled time and worked efficiently to complete the task in one day. Cleaned up well after installation was complete. Would use this company again.
Although the wait time to get scheduled was alittle long (not longer than they told us), it was surely worth the wait. The finished product is gorgeous! Our installer, Brian, was professional, conscientious, courteous, respectful & personable. LOVE our new walk-in shower!
Jordan and Ryan were so professional and got the project done in an efficient manner. They kept everything clean. The shower is awesome!! I'm very happy with everything from Mark the salesperson, Madasia the project manager and Jacob and Ryan as the installers. I couldn't be happier!
You can’t deny the product is great and a tad costly but it’s the best. Totally custom. The installer was even better. Accurate, clean, knowledgeable, and well spoken easy to understand.
I chose bath experts this time since their quality of work was much better than the other group. There was a difference of about 1500 but i went with Bath experts. They showed up on time, had their name on the van and shirts.
I got a tub to walk-in shower with glass doors and the experience was wonderful!!! I was as excited from the very beginning mostly due to Taesha as she was one of the best sales professional I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with. Installation was smooth and very clean. They represented great teamwork. Highly recommend.
Start Your Dream Bathroom Transformation in Indiana, Ohio, or Kentucky with a Free Quote
Are you ready to finally transform your outdated or inefficient bathroom into a beautiful, functional, and safe oasis? Bath Experts is your trusted, local bathroom remodeling partner specializing in high-quality, durable shower and bath systems across Indiana, Ohio, and Kentucky. Contact us today to schedule your free quote.
Contact Us
Indianapolis, IN 46268
Mon-Fri: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sat-Sun: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Fort Wayne, IN 46808
Mon-Fri: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sat-Sun: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Loveland, OH 45140
Mon-Fri: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sat-Sun: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Urbancrest, OH 43123
Mon-Fri: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sat-Sun: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131
Mon-Fri: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sat-Sun: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Jeffersontown, KY 40299
Mon-Fri: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sat-Sun: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Lexington, KY 40505
Mon-Fri: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sat-Sun: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Hobart, IN 46342
Mon-Fri: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sat-Sun: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM